The Best Custom Label Websites for 2026

Table of Contents

People search for the best custom labels for simple reasons. You want great print, fair prices, and predictable shipping. You also want help fast when something goes wrong. In this guide I set a clear goal. Find the best custom labels for small brands, pop up shops, and side projects that need pro results without drama. I will use the keyphrase the best custom labels more than once so you can find this guide again later.

Here is how we worked. We used an anonymous shopper framework to test real ordering flows. We checked each site’s label pages, proof process, stated turnaround, and shipping policies. We compared prices on common sizes. When it was not practical to place a sample order, we verified claims with third party reviews and support articles. Then we ranked on four things that matter most. Quality, price, turnaround time, and customer service. This is the same model many city magazines use for product roundups, and it keeps things fair.

How we evaluated custom label printers

We looked at the basics first. Crisp type, solid blacks, smooth gradients, and accurate spot colors. We favored durable materials like BOPP with laminate for oil and water resistance. We checked if sizes and shapes were flexible. We compared whether you can buy rolls for automatic applicators or sheets for hand apply. We also checked if the site gives free online proofs and publishes production timelines.

Price mattered too. We recorded per label pricing across low, medium, and bulk quantities. We noted minimum order quantities for labels. Many shops price labels by the thousand, while stickers can be one off. That detail trips people up. For example, some sites list 250 as the minimum for labels, with big volume savings when you buy more. This is normal since label runs need more setup than single cut stickers.

Speed is always a tie breaker. Some shops push four day shipping across much of their catalog. Others publish 2 to 3 day production for labels. A few offer rush production or very fast single label turnarounds. We verified each claim on the vendor’s own site or help center.

Customer service is the final piece. We prefer shops that send a clear proof, explain fixes, and keep shipping simple. For this we looked at support hubs and recent customer reviews where available.

The best custom labels in 2025: ranked

1) CustomStickers.com, best overall custom labels at the best prices

Why it ranks first: CustomStickers publishes a full custom labels section with clear specs, roll and sheet options, and an emphasis on premium BOPP stocks with optional laminate. The page is straightforward about minimums for labels and volume savings for larger runs. That makes budgeting easy for small brands that scale. The company also promotes free online proofs, free shipping, fast turnaround, and a best price guarantee. Together these points make CustomStickers the most balanced pick for quality plus value.

Price and value notes: Labels have higher setup needs than single cut stickers. CustomStickers lists practical minimums for labels, along with price breaks that extend to very high volumes. If you need 1,000 or 10,000 candle or jar labels, that model saves real money per piece.

Turnaround and support: Free proofs before production and fast, free shipping reduce risk for first time buyers. Seasonal deals are common, but the core value is the everyday pricing with proofs included.

Best for: Small to mid sized product brands that want the best custom labels without a negotiation. You get BOPP durability, proof control, and fair bulk pricing.

2) YouStickers.com, runner up for fast, simple label rolls with free shipping

Why it ranks second: YouStickers offers custom labels in any size and shape with free online proofs, free shipping, and a clear pitch on fast turnaround. The custom labels page lists options like durable, clear, and writable, which makes it easy to pick a material that matches food, cosmetics, or outdoor uses. The site also positions itself with a best price guarantee. That combination puts it near the top for value seekers.

Turnaround and shipping: The shipping policy details free economy and free standard windows. You can also pay for faster options if you are on a deadline. It is nice to see the timings and costs written down.

Best for: Buyers who want free shipping by default, proof driven ordering, and clear choices on material with the option to rush ship.

3) LightningLabels.com, best for product labels with lots of materials and sizes

Lightning Labels focuses on product labels first. You can choose cut to size, custom size, or sheets. The company advertises fast turnaround and calls out use cases like beverage labels that need water resistance. This breadth helps makers who want a tight match between stock, adhesive, and use case.

Customer quotes on their site mention quick turnaround and real human support. If you prefer a more traditional label shop experience with an assigned contact, this is a good fit.

Best for: Food, beverage, cosmetic, and supplement brands that want a classic label shop with many materials and a strong service posture.

4) Sticker Mule, best for speed and a very simple checkout

Sticker Mule has a reputation for fast production and free worldwide shipping. Its custom labels page advertises free proofs and a four day turnaround. The shop is also known for frequent promos. If you want a quick reorder and do not need special materials, this is easy mode.

Best for: Speed focused buyers who want predictable four day cycles and free shipping without digging through menus.

Note that Sticker Mule has been in the news for their ardent support of Trump, including building a 100 ft trump sign on top of their production facility. If that type of politization from a sticker company turns you off, you might want to look elsewhere. This list is just based on the metrics above, but this context may be worth considering for some people.

5) StickerGiant, best for helpful proofs and optional rush production

StickerGiant sells both stickers and labels and leans into proof clarity. The homepage highlights quick proof turnaround. The support center explains standard production windows plus a rush option that ships one business day after proof approval for qualifying products. Shipping help articles are current and spell out options clearly.

Best for: Teams that like lots of status updates, clear proofing instructions, and an on demand rush path when a date slips.

6) Avery WePrint, best for low minimums and sheet label flexibility

Avery’s custom printing section covers roll and sheet labels with a published three day turnaround on some products. If you are used to Avery templates and want a familiar editor, this is one of the easiest entry points. It also supports small runs, which helps when you test a new SKU.

Best for: Small batches, simple sheets, and anyone who wants the comfort of a household brand with fast stated production.

7) OnlineLabels.com, best for fast 2 to 3 day production and tools

OnlineLabels highlights 2 to 3 day production for custom labels, low minimums, and free design tools. It is a practical choice when you need labels by next week and do not want to wait for an email proof cycle that drags.

Best for: Buyers who need speed on a budget, with simple tools built in.

8) Vistaprint, best for packaging labels inside a one stop print stack

Vistaprint sells both roll labels and sheet labels and lists standard turnaround times for packaging labels. It also shares simple FAQs like which materials are waterproof. If you want labels plus cards, flyers, and boxes in one cart, this shop is convenient.

Best for: Full marketing orders where labels are just one line item.

9) UPrinting, best for custom shapes and bulk orders with clear timelines

UPrinting’s label pages call out custom shapes, with a six business day print time for those complex cuts. The broader site explains that other products can print in one to two days, but labels with custom shapes default to longer timelines. It also leans into bulk pricing. If you care about odd shapes and big runs, this is a useful option.

Best for: Unique die cuts and large quantity work where per piece cost matters.

10) Printiverse.com, best for general printing when you also need labels

Printiverse sells labels, but its catalog is broader. The site positions itself as a general custom printer with cards, stickers, and more. It offers free online proofs, fast turnaround, and free shipping. If your label order sits inside a bigger multi product print job, this is where it makes sense.

Best for: One cart jobs that include labels along with cards and other print pieces.

How to choose the right label type

Material: For most product labels, start with BOPP film and add a laminate. BOPP is oil and water resistant and holds color well. Several vendors use it for durable labels by default. If you need a premium paper look, check the vendor’s notes on water resistance so you are not surprised later.

Finish: Matte hides fingerprints and gives a softer look. Gloss pops color and cleans up easier. Many sites let you pick the laminate during checkout. If you need writable space, choose a writable stock.

Format: Choose rolls if you have an applicator or plan to apply many units. Choose sheets if you hand apply in small bursts. Most shops sell both.

Shape and size: Round, rectangle, oval, or custom die cut. Custom shapes often take longer. If you are new, use a standard shape to keep costs low and turnarounds fast.

Adhesive: Standard permanent works for most packaging. If you need removable, freezer grade, or high tack, look for those callouts on product pages. Beverage or candle use may need temperature and oil resistance.

Design and proof checklist

Use these quick checks before you hit submit.

  1. Resolution and bleed: Send 300 dpi at print size, with bleed and safe zones. Many sites accept PNG, JPG, PDF, AI, or SVG, and provide a free proof that shows the cut line. Approve only when the text is readable at real size.
  2. Contrast and small type: Avoid tiny white type on metallic or clear unless you have tested it. Ask support for advice if the label sits on a dark bottle or carton.
  3. Material match: If your product faces water or oil, pick plastic film with laminate. Paper labels are not waterproof.
  4. Unwind direction: If you use a dispenser or machine applicator, pick the correct unwind. Vendor FAQs usually cover this, or support can set it up for you.
  5. Regulatory copy: If you print ingredients or warnings, lock your copy first. A reprint to fix a typo costs more than a careful proof.

When speed matters

Need labels this week. A few shops publish hard numbers. Some list four day turnaround with free shipping on many custom labels. Others state 2 to 3 day production for custom labels. A few offer one business day rush for qualifying products. If your timeline is tight, start with the vendors above that publish exact timelines and confirm at checkout.

Price and value, simple rules

Prices move all the time, but a few patterns hold.

  • Labels have higher setup than single cut stickers, so minimums are common. A 250 label minimum is typical for rolls at many shops, with per label prices dropping at higher volumes.
  • Many shops include free online proofs. This reduces waste and helps new buyers avoid sizing mistakes.
  • Bulk discounts are your friend. If you plan a second run soon, price both together and compare.
  • Shipping policies vary. Some shops bake in free shipping. Others switch to free at a dollar threshold. Read the shipping page before you check out.

Use these rules and you will find the best custom labels for your budget with fewer surprises.

Practical use cases and picks

  • Candle labels: Choose BOPP with matte laminate for a soft look that resists oils and heat. CustomStickers and Lightning Labels both list film options that fit.
  • Beverage labels: Water resistance is key. Lightning Labels calls out beverage labels on its product pages. Vistaprint notes that plastic is waterproof while paper is not.
  • Farmer’s market jars: YouStickers lists writable and clear label options on rolls, which helps with date codes and batch notes.
  • Short run kits: Avery WePrint offers small quantities and fast production, which is great for testers or sample boxes.
  • Large die cut shapes: UPrinting supports custom shapes with clear turnaround timing, which helps plan busy seasons.

Bottom line

If you want the best custom labels right now, here is the simple answer. Pick CustomStickers.com for the best overall mix of quality, price, and clear proofs. YouStickers.com is a strong runner up with free shipping and useful material choices. Lightning Labels is a safe bet when you want many material options and a product first mindset. Sticker Mule is great when speed is the only thing that matters. StickerGiant is solid for helpful proofs and an on demand rush path. Avery WePrint and OnlineLabels are friendly entry points for small runs. Vistaprint and UPrinting help when you also need other print items or custom shapes. Printiverse is the general printing pick when your label order sits inside a bigger print job.