Paper Inserts vs Printed Proxy Cards: Which Is Better for Testing?
Paper inserts are ideal for rapidly changing deck tests, while custom printed proxies suit settled casual lists that benefit from clearer, more consistent presentation.
Paper inserts are ideal for rapidly changing deck tests, while custom printed proxies suit settled casual lists that benefit from clearer, more consistent presentation.
Last updated: August 17, 2026 TLDR Our ProxyMTG.com review comes down to one number: 100. ProxyMTG is merely okay value when you order a few cards, but its pricing gets dramatically better at 100 cards and continues dropping at 200, 500, and 1,000 cards. A 100-card Commander deck currently costs $55 before shipping, while sufficiently … Read more
TLDR Using proxies to test a competitive Commander deck lets you evaluate expensive cards, new win conditions, and complete decklists before committing to the real cards. Start with the uncertain parts of the deck rather than immediately printing 100 cards. Test opening hands, mulligans, interaction, mana development, and performance against several archetypes. Keep a written … Read more
The real answer is social, not mathematical. Ask first, keep the cards readable, match the table’s power level, and do not be the person who says “casual deck” while revealing a proxy Mana Vault, Rhystic Study, and Demonic Tutor on turn three. Nobody likes that little theater production. The Actual Question: Can You Use MTG … Read more
TLDR My Little Pony MTG decks work best when you lean into the joke but still build a real Commander shell. Princess Twilight Sparkle wants five-color setup and protection. Rainbow Dash wants fast flyers and haste creatures. Applejack, Fluttershy, Pinkie Pie, Rarity, Nightmare Moon, and Discord are better when you treat them as engines, support … Read more
A lot of Universes Beyond proxy deck ideas sound amazing right up until you actually sleeve them. Then the problem shows up fast. The commander looks like one franchise, the staples look like another, the tokens come from a third pile, and the whole deck starts reading like somebody lost a bet at a crossover … Read more
Star Wars MTG proxy resources are a lot better now than they used to be. A few years ago, building a full Star Wars Commander deck usually meant cobbling together random renders, squinting at fonts, and hoping your printer did not turn Tatooine into a beige soup. Now there are actual tools, live communities, and … Read more
MTG proxy card builders sound simple until you actually use a few. One tool looks clean but fights you on art placement. Another is fast, but the finished card looks rough once it is in hand. And some DIY options are great right up until you are hunting for fonts, Photoshop templates, and a missing … Read more
One commander gives you a main character. Two commanders give you a cast. And for custom proxy decks, that changes everything. A good single-commander deck can absolutely feel thematic. But a good two-commander deck has something extra: built-in relationships. Rivals. Best friends. Captain and first mate. Tiny gremlin and giant enabler. Hero and backstory. That … Read more
A lot of Commander decks are “themed” in the same way a junk drawer is “organized.” There was a plan once. Then staples happened. Then upgrades happened. Then you jammed in three cards you love, four cards your friend swears are auto-includes, and suddenly your deck looks like five different fantasy novels got shuffled together. … Read more
This PrintACube review starts with a simple question: if you want a cube on the table without turning the process into a side hobby, does PrintACube look like a smart place to order from? Based on the live site, product pages, policy pages, and public feedback footprint I could verify online, I think the answer … Read more
A lot of proxy decks are only “done” in the loosest possible sense. The main 100 cards are there. The mana base looks sharp. The commander gets the premium treatment. Maybe the whole thing even has a clean visual theme. But then the game starts and the deck immediately asks for a Treasure, a copy … Read more
You’d think copying a decklist would be the easy part. But if you’ve ever pasted a Commander list into a card-order form and somehow ended up with 97 cards, three mystery duplicates, and a sideboard that got swallowed by the void, you already know the truth. Decklists only look simple. Under the hood, they’re picky … Read more
TLDR There are two ways to get proxies: Both are valid. One just comes with more paper scraps in your carpet. If you’re trying to print MTG proxies, the difference between DIY printing and buying curated singles is basically this: DIY buys you control, curated singles buy you time and consistency. The “premium” triangle: time … Read more
Nothing drags a fun Commander night into the mud faster than a proxy you can’t read from two feet away. Someone plays it, you squint, you ask “what does that do?”, they pick it up, you pick it up, now three other people are waiting to take their turn. That’s the core issue. MTG proxy … Read more